Ottawa Citizen Review of Lucky So-and-So

Posted on Sep 14, 2014 in Blog, Music | 2 comments

Melinda Whitaker Victoria- CD LaunchVancouver Island-based singer Melinda Whitaker has seasoned, unabashedly jazz-based approach to singing, and she’s perfectly paired on her disc Lucky S0-And-So by Vancouver Island’s premier jazzman, Phil Dwyer.

The CD finds Dwyer handling multiple responsibilities, including producer, arranger, musical director, piano and saxophones. He basically did everything except the catering for the sessions.

Dwyer’s arrangements are rich and fully formed, with nice details, reharmonizations and the like. There are even some hidden little Easter eggs for jazz fans, such as the citation of Killer Joe at the end of the title track, or Two Bass Hit embedded in Just Friends.

It’s telling that disc’s saucy opener The Song Is You features a drum solo after Whittaker’s spirited delivery of the theme, plus a Dwyer piano solo on a grid that involves the slick insertion of some Giant Steps changes.

Dwyer has no shortage of moves in his arranging kit. My Foolish Heart is floating straight eighth tunes with fine horn backgrounds. Stevie Wonder’s Overjoyed works just fine as a jazz waltz. Jobim’s Felicidade rings with addition of Pat Coleman’s guitar. The title track and Just Friends are testaments to Whitaker’s natural, swinging feel.

Of course, Whitaker and Dwyer at the piano need no bells and whistles when they perform You’ve Changed as moving duet to close the CD.


  1. Excellent (and well written) review Melinda..congratulations.
    It was a delight and a privilege to have you perform many of these tunes WITH Phi at our annual Jazz, Tea & Cheesecake Concert in July of 2013. We still get comments.

    Keep swinging,
    Ray & Judy
    Little Qualicum Cheeseworks
    Parksville, B.C.

    • Hi Ray and Judy,

      Thanks so very much for your kind words. I loved performing at Little Qualicum Cheeseworks.

      This Saturday evening, September 20th, I’ll be performing in The Bengal Room at the Fairmont Empress in Victoria. If you’re in town, do drop by!

      Cheers, Melinda

Leave a Reply to Ray Haynes Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *